MLB’s Playoff Format Needs a Rethink—and the AL East Shows Why
Sports

MLB’s Playoff Format Needs a Rethink—and the AL East Shows Why

Joe Soccoa
September 22, 2026· 8 min read
Share

The Yankees, Red Sox and Rays do not deserve special treatment. Every contender deserves a postseason structure that properly rewards winning.

A playoff format should answer a straightforward question: What did a team earn by winning more games?

Not what television matchup would be most attractive. Not which division happened to offer the most manageable road. Not where a team landed on a bracket that cannot change once October begins. Winning should produce a meaningful competitive advantage, and the better the season, the stronger that advantage should be.

That is why Major League Baseball needs to take a serious look at its postseason structure. The developing American League bracket presents a compelling reason to reconsider both how teams are seeded and what happens after the opening round.

The projected matchup is Yankees–Red Sox, with the winner advancing to face the Rays. 

If those positions hold, exactly one of those three teams will reach the American League Championship Series. That is not a prediction about who will play well or poorly. It is a mathematical consequence of putting all three on the same side of the bracket. 

Entering September 21, Tampa Bay, New York and Boston held the American League’s three best records. 

That does not mean they are entitled to advance. It does mean baseball should ask whether its bracket appropriately reflects what those clubs accomplished.

This Is About Winning, Not Protecting Certain Teams

The easiest way to dismiss this argument is to call it a complaint from Yankees or Red Sox fans who do not like their potential opponents. That misses the point.

No team deserves a protected path because of its name, payroll, history or market size. The Yankees should have to earn their way through October. So should the Red Sox. So should the Rays. If Cleveland, Texas or another contender beats them, the result should be celebrated—not explained away.

But there is a difference between accepting an upset and defending the structure that determines who must play whom.

A fair postseason does not guarantee that the best regular-season teams will survive. It should, however, distribute the rewards of the regular season as consistently as possible. Otherwise, we are asking clubs to pursue excellence for six months and then telling some of them that their place in the division matters more than their place in the league.

Under MLB’s rules, division winners receive the first three seeds, regardless of whether a wild-card club has a better record. 

Winning a division should matter. The question is how much.

Should it guarantee a playoff berth? Absolutely. Should it automatically place a team ahead of every wild-card qualifier, even one with a substantially stronger season? That deserves a more serious debate.

A division championship and a superior regular-season record are two different achievements. Baseball can recognize both without pretending they are always the same thing.

Reseeding Is a Start—but Not the Entire Solution

MLB does not reseed after the Wild Card Series. 

That should change.

Once the opening round ends, the highest remaining seed should face the lowest remaining seed. The other two survivors should meet in the second Division Series. A bracket should not prevent the top seed from receiving the matchup its ranking would ordinarily warrant.

Consider a hypothetical opening round in which the No. 6 seed advances. Under a reseeding system, that club would face No. 1. That is a simple, understandable reward for finishing at the top: the highest seed draws the lowest surviving seed.

It would not guarantee an easier series. A sixth seed could have outstanding pitching, favorable matchups or a healthier roster than its record suggests. Seeding cannot measure every October variable. It can establish a consistent principle rather than ask the league to predict which opponent is actually most dangerous.

But there is an important distinction in this year’s discussion: reseeding alone would not necessarily separate the Rays from the Yankees–Red Sox winner.

Suppose the four remaining seeds were 1, 2, 3 and 4. Reseeding would still produce 1 against 4. If they were 1, 2, 3 and 5, it would produce 1 against 5. Changing opponents after the opening round cannot fully correct a system that assigned its original seeds primarily around division championships.

That is why the conversation needs to go beyond simply adding reseeding. MLB must also reconsider how teams get those seeds in the first place.

Keep the Division Races. Reward the Better Records.

My preferred approach would preserve six playoff teams in each league: the three division champions and three wild cards. Every division winner would retain an automatic postseason berth.

Once those six teams qualified, however, they would be seeded by regular-season record, using established tiebreaking procedures when necessary. The two highest seeds would receive byes. The remaining four would play 3 against 6 and 4 against 5, with the higher seeds hosting. After that round, the survivors would be reseeded.

Currently, the byes belong to the two division winners with the best records in each league. 

Under this proposal, those byes would instead belong to the two best records among the qualifiers—even if both teams came from the same division.

That is a meaningful change, and it should be acknowledged as one. A division title would no longer automatically bring a top-three seed or guarantee hosting the opening round. Its reward would be entry into the postseason. The quality of the full season would determine the advantages a team received once it got there.

Apply that principle to a hypothetical league whose three best records belong to one division. Those clubs would become seeds 1, 2 and 3 rather than being pushed into positions that force them into the same early-round path. Two could still lose before the championship series. All three could still underperform. Nothing would be promised.

But their opportunity would be organized around what they earned.

The objective should not be to keep division rivals apart. Sometimes they should meet immediately. The objective should be to stop giving division status more weight than the overall results when assigning postseason advantages.

Teams Must Think Beyond This Year’s Bracket

MLB’s clubs also need to approach this debate with more than their immediate interests in mind.

An organization that benefits from the current structure this September could be disadvantaged by it next September. A division can become more competitive. A rival can improve. A club can build an excellent roster and still finish behind another excellent roster.

The right question for an owner or baseball operations department is not, “Does this format help us right now?” It is, “Would we consider this fair if we finished with one of the league’s best records and still received a worse starting position?”

That is where the competitive argument becomes important.

A postseason system should make an additional regular-season victory worth pursuing whenever it can improve a team’s position. Clubs would still weigh health, rest and pitching preparation against the value of another win. But the format should make the reward for climbing the standings as clear as possible.

There is also an organizational principle involved. If teams are being asked to invest in depth, development and sustained competitiveness, the rules should give those achievements meaningful value. Building a stronger regular-season team should not become less useful simply because another strong organization shares its division.

This is not an argument for guaranteeing anyone more postseason revenue or more October home games. It is an argument for making competitive rewards follow competitive results.

Fairness Does Not Mean Eliminating October’s Uncertainty

There are legitimate objections. Division races could lose some importance if titles no longer guaranteed premium seeding. Reseeding would create additional uncertainty for travel, ticketing and opponent preparation. And record-based seeding is not a perfect measure of quality; a truly comprehensive review should also examine how comparable each club’s schedule is.

Those are issues to address, not reasons to avoid the discussion.

Division titles would still deliver guaranteed postseason access. Reseeding could be planned around a clearly published calendar. And an imperfect measure of achievement can still be preferable to a system that deliberately places a better-record team behind a worse-record team.

Most importantly, this should be a future reform—not a last-minute attempt to rearrange the 2026 postseason. Teams deserve to play under the rules established before their season began.

The familiar response will remain: A championship team has to beat whoever is in front of it.

Of course it does.

But that is an expectation for the players, not a complete defense of the bracket. Teams should focus on winning their next series. The league should focus on making sure the structure of those series is fair.

The Rays, Yankees and Red Sox make the issue visible this year. The principle should apply just as strongly when the teams involved are smaller-market clubs, unfamiliar contenders or organizations with no national rivalry to sell.

October should decide who is best when the games matter most. The regular season should decide who earned the strongest starting position. MLB needs a format that respects both.

#MLB#Playoffs#WildCardSeries#Yankees#RedSox#Rays

Joe Soccoa

The Founder who always contributes. Thanks Dave Portnoy.

@CrossTalk Media Network@JoeSoccoa3@Crosstalkmediahub

Comments

Sign in to join the conversation.

No comments yet. Be the first!